Comparing Asphalt and Rubber as Home Roofing Solutions 

roof shingle background and texture. dark asphalt tiles on the roof.

The roofing process has evolved tremendously over the last hundred years – and the materials used to protect your home have followed suit. Some homeowners in Southeastern Pennsylvania may go for a tried-and-true material for their roof, such as cedar shake. While this option remains popular, a few others have joined its ranks for their durability, style options, and longevity.

In this article, we will discuss the two most common types of modern roofing materials chosen by homeowners around the region – asphalt shingles, and rubber.

Asphalt shingles

If you look around most modern suburban neighborhoods – especially on the east coast –  you’ll find that asphalt shingles have taken root as the most popular roofing material. Compared to other options, asphalt shingles are the most affordable. Homeowners on a strict budget can rest easy knowing that they will have enough to cover the rest of their home’s overall cost. They are also very adaptable in terms of style. The actual shingles come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and there are even premium options available that offer extra structural support. They come in a variety of colors, as well, so they’ll fit well into any environment.

On the installation side, asphalt shingles are an architectural blessing to roofers. Because they are so lightweight, they’re easy to fit into place. For those who value their time, asphalt is the easy answer, as these shingles require little prep work and the entire roofing process will happen within a much shorter time frame. Replacement is also relatively easy and quick.

Even an easily-adaptable and time-tested material like asphalt comes with a few downsides, however. Their lightweight structure makes them more susceptible to cracking. This can occur due to weather conditions, like strong wind or quick temperature changes. Weather is also a factor for the timetable of installation, since the shingles need to be installed while the temperature is warm enough to prevent material damage. 

Rubber shingles

Nowadays, you may drive through a neighborhood with roofs that all look the same without realizing that some homeowners have selected a different material. Rubber, the newest addition to the traditional roofing material list, can be fashioned to look just like other materials – even asphalt. Synthetic blends aren’t as time-honored as other options, but they do pose some interesting benefits.

Rubber shingles are often recycled from other objects, such as old tires, making them one of the most environmentally conscious options on the market. Rubber also provides great protection in multiple ways – it is very fire-resistant, and provides a highly-durable shield against adverse weather conditions. Rubber roofing provides great insulation, especially when it is manufactured to include air-trapping pockets.

The drawbacks to rubber as a roofing material are somewhat predictable. The material has a strong smell, and while it fades over time, its initial presence can be jarring to family members and neighbors. The other major drawback is that rubber roofing is much less visually adaptable than asphalt, often only coming in black or white.

Regardless of the roofing material you decide to use for your home, you should be sure to research the best and most reliable installation service available. J L Roofing & Siding boasts a team of experienced professionals that take pride in their work throughout Pennsylvania. Besides our excellent roofing services, we offer options for your entire home – siding, doors, windows, gutters, waterproofing, and more. Visit our website to see a full list of services available. When you’re ready, set up a free consultation with us to begin bringing your vision to life.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest